Welcome to Maguire Subaru of Ithaca
Maguire Subaru of Ithaca, located at 320 Elmira Rd, is celebrated for delivering exceptional car-buying experiences. Customers praise the friendly and efficient team, highlighting their no-nonsense approach and transparent pricing. Many have expressed satisfaction with the swift process, often completing purchases in under an hour, showcasing the dealership’s commitment to valuing time. The knowledgeable sales staff listen attentively to needs, guiding buyers to the perfect vehicles—like the popular Subaru Crosstrek and Forester. With a focus on professionalism and customer care, Maguire Subaru stands out as a go-to destination for first-time and seasoned car buyers alike in Ithaca and beyond.
-
320 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States Hotline: +1 607-273-8585
Welcome to Maguire Subaru of Ithaca, a prominent name in the automotive scene nestled at 320 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY. Specializing in delivering exceptional customer service and an impressive lineup of vehicles, Maguire Subaru stands out not just for its quality cars but also for its commitment to creating a delightful purchasing experience.
With a focus on transparency and customer satisfaction, Maguire Subaru of Ithaca has garnered a reputation among locals. Customer reviews highlight a consistent emphasis on friendly, efficient service. For instance, Samantha Detrick recalls a smooth first-time car purchase, praising the friendly sales approach and the swift transaction that got her on the road in no time.
The sales team, described as incredibly helpful and detail-oriented, ensures that every customer's needs are met. Leeann Sowers' experience echoes this sentiment—she appreciated Matthew's preparedness and straightforward negotiation, feeling respected and understood throughout her buying journey.
Moreover, the dealership prides itself on a no-pressure environment, allowing customers like Chris Williams to feel at ease when making significant financial decisions. He refers to his leasing experience of the new 2025 Subaru Forester as "painless" and highlights the importance of timely communication, a crucial factor that resonates with many buyers.
Braden's exceptional service also warrants mention. Customer Kristopher Bosela enjoyed a seamless transaction, complemented by frequent updates, making the purchase process feel transparent and straightforward. And let's not forget the extra mile that Cameron went, demonstrating immense patience and flexibility during decision-making, even coming in on his day off to assist customers.
All in all, Maguire Subaru of Ithaca embodies all the qualities that one would wish for in a car dealership—integrity, transparency, and a customer-first philosophy. With numerous testimonials backing up its glowing reputation, this dealership proves to be a worthwhile destination for those in search of their next vehicle. If you're considering a new car, make sure to pay them a visit; their friendly crew is ready to guide you through every step of your journey.
Bought my first new car at Maguire with Tyler and my whole experience was great ! He was super friendly, efficient, and thorough. I test drove a few cars one day and we were in and out the next within 20 minutes! I will definitely be returning for my next car but hopefully not for a long time :)
I recently had a fantastic experience purchasing my first vehicle at Subaru Maguire, thanks to their exceptional sales and finance team. A friend recommended them after her own positive experience, and I’m so glad I reached out. From the start, Matthew in sales was incredibly helpful. I knew exactly what vehicle I wanted, even down to the stock number. He had the car ready for me when I arrived later that day, showing that he valued my time and effort in researching the right choice. The negotiation process was straightforward and fair. Matthew listened to my needs and worked hard to keep the monthly payments within my budget while also fitting in a 7-year/100k-mile warranty. I felt respected and understood throughout the entire process. Overall, Subaru Maguire provided a welcoming and professional environment that made my first car purchase a breeze. Thank you, Matthew and the team, for your support and dedication!
Painless. Quick. Easy. Usually drove the family hammy-downs. Felt great about leasing a new 2025 Subaru Forester after years of saving up. Just got the car but I’m feeling great about my purchase. Highly recommend stopping in to see the crew before these potential tariffs take effect.
My wife and I were helped by Braden and he made the experience seamless and easy. It was a pleasure working with him and this company. even though the process takes time we felt that Braden was always giving us timely updates, checking in frequently, and communicating clearly. And on top of that, we love our new car!
Thanks to Cameron for his patience with us as we decided between two Crosstreks. He rewrote the paperwork when we changed our mind & even came in on his scheduled day off. The battery died & he sent out Braydon with a new one complimentary. Think we got a good deal & are ready to vroom vroom!
Dillon made this experience so easy! I came from an hour away to look at a very specific Subaru Forester I had seen online, and he answered my online inquiry in less than an hour. We set up an appointment for 9:45 am and I had everything approved and signed by 11:30. There were no gimmicks or pressure, just honest support of the process. I couldn't recommend Maguire more!
They did an excellent job start to finish! They quoted the lowest OTD even with a dealer trade. Tyler and his team made the whole process easy and seamless. They value your business and your time! This is my second car from Maguire dealerships in Ithaca and I definitely recommend them especially to anyone in the Binghamton area, don't shop Matthews! Take the short lovely drive and shop Maguire's! I love my new Subaru Crosstrek! Thank you all so much!
Bought a brand new Crosstrek. Found the car online and the prices were the lowest in upstate New York. Actually travelled over 60 miles to purchase. Very transparent pricing with no hidden markups or silly fees. Was in and out in 30 minutes. They will be my go to guys for all my new car needs in the future.